Smoking Cessation Counseling: How To Talk With Your Patients

Tobacco use is a cause of significant morbidity and mortality worldwide, and smoking cessation counseling is a priority recommendation for physicians and healthcare providers to implement routinely in clinical visits. 

Although the health risks are well-documented – tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable death in the U.S., and is associated with cancer and coronary heart disease – for the first time in 20 years, while small, we saw an increase in cigarette sales in the U.S. 

Quitting smoking is hard. The vast majority of former smokers report quitting without the use of any smoking cessation aid, but conversely each quit attempt without a cessation aid results in 6% likelihood of success.

By engaging in frequent dialogue with patients, and by sharing their cessation options with them, providers can help patients to quit smoking in the way that works best for the patient.

Learn more about how to support your patients with smoking cessation

Counseling

Motivational Interviewing

Motivational interviewing is a discussion technique where the healthcare professional words questions to the patient in such a way that the patient describes positive reasons for wanting to quit smoking and confidence in their ability to quit smoking. This interview technique roughly doubles the patient’s success in quitting smoking and has been shown to not increase the time of the patient visit, despite provider concerns of smoking cessation counseling being time-consuming.

Here are some examples of questions you might ask your patient to help start a conversation. 

  1. On a scale of 1-10, one being low priority and 10 being high priority, describe your willingness to quit smoking today. 
  2. What are some of the reasons you are at [number]? The patient then explains positive reasons why they are willing to quit smoking. 
  3. On a scale from 1-10, one being low and 10 being high, what is your confidence that you can quit smoking?
  4. Why is it not a [lower number]? This allows the patient to voice their confidence that they can quit smoking.

Additional Approaches

Tobacco and smoking cessation counseling is effective and can be delivered briefly or through more intense, multidisciplinary sessions, depending on what you and the patient decide together. In addition to motivational interviewing, some additional approaches include the following.

The Five As

  1. Ask about tobacco use
  2. Advise to quit through clear, personalized messages
  3. Assess willingness to quit
  4. Assist in quitting
  5. Arrange follow up and support

Ask, Advise, Refer

  1. Ask about tobacco use
  2. Advise to quit using
  3. Refer for follow up

Vital Sign

Record smoking status at every health visit as an assessment of tobacco use.

Medication

In addition to counseling, medications can also greatly improve the quit rate for each quit attempt. Nicotine replacement therapy is often available without a prescription. Varenicline use results in a higher sustained quit rate at 12 months than other alternatives.

Intervention% Increase in Abstinence at Six Months
Health provider counseling18-96%
Nicotine replacement therapy (NRT)53-68%
Bupropion SR49-76%
Varenicline102-155%
Source: Interventions for Tobacco Smoking Cessation in Adults, Including Pregnant Persons: US Preventive Services Task Force Recommendation Statement
Medication ExamplesDosing Examples
NRT – nicotine patches15 cigarettes per day or more: 21 mcg daily for 3-4 weeks, 14 mcg daily for 3-4 weeks then 7 mcg daily for 3-4 weeks. May continue longer at any dose. Long-term NRT is safe.
NRT – nicotine gum 2mg for < 25 cigarettes per day, and 4 mg for  25 cigarettes per day or more. Place one piece of gum in the mouth and chew for a few seconds, then “park” the gum between the teeth and the cheek. When another burst of nicotine is desired chew the gum for a few seconds. Start with 9 pieces of gum per day for the first 6 weeks.
Bupropion SR12-hour formulation: Start 150 mg daily for 3 days then 1 tablet twice a day. Continue therapy for 12-24 weeks. 
VareniclineStarter pack: 0.5 mg daily for 3 days, then 0.5 mg bid x 4 days, then 1 mg bid for 3 weeks. Quit smoking on day 7 – 35.Continuing pack: 1 mg bid x 4 weeksDuration of therapy 12-24 weeks and some evidence shows may be safe for 1 year. May re-treat if relapse occurs.

Despite the clear benefit of tobacco and smoking cessation counseling and intervention, there is low implementation in practice. As few as 20% of healthcare appointments with smokers result in assessment of tobacco use and only 7% leave with a prescription for a smoking cessation aid. Physicians struggle with perceived time intensity of interventions as well as negative attitudes toward tobacco addiction. Increased provider education as well as accommodation in the office visit workflow for tobacco and smoking cessation intervention may increase use of these tools to help patients quit smoking.

Published December 20, 2021

Amy Dawson, MD, MPH, FAAFP
Family medicine physician


Join the Conversation

Register for Figure 1 and be part of the largest global community of healthcare professionals exchanging knowledge to improve patient outcomes.